The Future of Cyber Careers: Inside America's Push for an Independent Cyber Force
How the Commission on Cyber Force Generation could reshape cybersecurity careers and create unprecedented opportunities in military cyber operations
The Career Revolution You Need to Know About
The cybersecurity career landscape is on the brink of a massive transformation. In 2025, a high-profile commission launched by the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) and the Foundation for Defense of Democracies (FDD) is examining whether the United States should establish an independent Cyber Force as a sixth military branch—a move that could create thousands of new career opportunities and fundamentally change how cyber professionals advance in government service.
My Privacy Blog
For cybersecurity professionals, this isn't just another policy discussion. This initiative represents the potential for an entirely new career ecosystem that could offer better advancement opportunities, specialized training, and clearer professional pathways than currently exist in traditional military services.
Why This Matters for Your Career
The Current Career Bottleneck
If you've ever considered a career in military cybersecurity, you've likely encountered a frustrating reality: the existing system wasn't built for cyber professionals. Here's what's broken:
Security Careers
Misaligned Promotion Tracks: Current military promotion systems reward command experience in traditional fields over technical cyber expertise. A brilliant malware analyst might be passed over for promotion because they haven't led an infantry platoon—a requirement that has nothing to do with their cyber mission effectiveness.
Service Fragmentation: The Army, Navy, Air Force, and Marines each manage their own cyber personnel separately, creating inconsistent standards, training, and career progression paths. There's no unified understanding of what makes a cyber professional successful across services.
Security Careers
Recruitment Challenges: Military recruiters often struggle to attract the right cyber talent because they're using approaches designed for traditional military roles. The ideal cyber recruit might come from a high school robotics club rather than the football team, requiring entirely different outreach strategies.
The Opportunity Ahead
An independent Cyber Force could change everything for cyber professionals:
Specialized Career Paths: Instead of competing with tank commanders for promotion, cyber professionals would advance within a system designed specifically for their skills and expertise.
Direct Commissioning Opportunities: Following the Space Force model, a Cyber Force could offer direct commission opportunities for civilian cyber experts, allowing industry professionals to enter military service at appropriate ranks without traditional military background requirements.
Security Careers
Technical Leadership Roles: Senior positions would be filled by people who understand the technical aspects of cyber operations, not just general military leadership principles.
Inside the Commission: What Industry Leaders Are Saying
The Commission on Cyber Force Generation brings together some of the most influential voices in cybersecurity and defense policy. Here's what key figures are advocating:
The Leadership Team
Mark Montgomery, Executive Director of the Cyberspace Solarium Commission 2.0 and Senior Director at FDD, argues that "The U.S. Cyber Force needs to have an extremely robust Guard and Reserve component construct, including the ability to rapidly and flexibly get people on orders on an ad hoc and on-demand basis."
Dr. Erica Lonergan, Assistant Professor at Columbia University and former lead writer of the 2023 U.S. Department of Defense Cyber Strategy, brings deep policy expertise to implementation questions.
Rep. Mike Gallagher, former co-chair of the Cyberspace Solarium Commission, has been pushing for congressional action, stating that "all solutions are on the table except the status quo" when it comes to fixing cyber force readiness.
Security Careers
Industry Backing
The commission has garnered support from major industry players who recognize the career development challenges in current systems. Companies like Palo Alto Networks, represented by Vice President John Davis, are actively participating in discussions about how to better integrate private sector expertise with military cyber operations.
The Numbers Behind the Need
Understanding the scale of this initiative helps illustrate the career opportunities it could create:
Proposed Scale: The FDD study suggests a Cyber Force with approximately 10,000 personnel and a $16.5 billion budget—comparable to the Space Force's current size but focused entirely on cyber operations.
Current Gaps: The number of U.S. offensive and defensive cyber forces has remained effectively static over the past 15 years despite growing cyber threats. Over the same period, China has invested heavily in cyber warfare, with cyber troop levels now estimated to be 10 times larger than those of the U.S. military.
Growth Potential: An independent service focused solely on cyber operations could scale up much more rapidly and effectively than the current distributed model across four services.
What This Means for Different Career Stages
Entry-Level Professionals
New Pathways: A Cyber Force could create entirely new enlisted and officer career tracks designed specifically for cyber roles, from network defenders to offensive cyber operators.
Educational Partnerships: Following the Space Force model, expect potential partnerships with universities and coding bootcamps to create cyber-specific educational pathways.
Competitive Advantages: Early adopters who join a new Cyber Force could benefit from rapid advancement opportunities as the service builds its ranks and leadership structure.
Mid-Career Transitions
Lateral Entry Opportunities: The most exciting prospect for experienced cybersecurity professionals is the potential for direct commissioning programs that recognize civilian cyber experience.
Guard and Reserve Components: The Cyber Force could draw on lessons from the Space Force, which has encountered few issues filling its new roles even though it requires highly technical and skilled personnel. A robust Guard/Reserve component could allow industry professionals to serve part-time while maintaining civilian careers.
Leadership Fast-Track: Experienced professionals could find themselves in senior positions more quickly than in traditional military services, as the new force builds its command structure.
Security Careers
Senior Executives
Strategic Roles: Senior industry leaders could play crucial roles in shaping doctrine, training, and operational concepts for a new service.
Advisory Positions: The commission process itself demonstrates the value placed on industry expertise in shaping military cyber capabilities.
Cross-Sector Opportunities: A Cyber Force would likely create new opportunities for movement between government, military, and private sector roles.
The Skills That Will Matter Most
Based on the commission's discussions and the Space Force precedent, certain skills are likely to be particularly valuable:
Technical Expertise
- Advanced persistent threat (APT) analysis
- Cloud security architecture
- Artificial intelligence and machine learning applications
- Post-quantum cryptography
- Industrial control systems security
Emerging Technology Areas
- AI models, such as Large Language Models (LLMs) and generative models, while providing exponential opportunities, have also reduced barriers to entry for the undertaking of malicious ICT activities
- Quantum computing implications for cybersecurity
- 5G and next-generation network security
- Internet of Things (IoT) security at scale
My Privacy Blog
Strategic and Policy Skills
- Cyber warfare doctrine development
- International cyber law and norms
- Public-private partnership management
- Cross-domain operational planning
Learning from the Space Force Success Story
The Space Force provides a valuable precedent for what a Cyber Force might look like:
Recruitment Success: The Space Force, which currently has 8,400 billets, attributes much of its recruiting success to being small, agile, and selective with applicants. Its leaders understand they do not need to mimic the larger services.
Direct Commissioning: The Space Force has successfully used direct commissioning to bring in civilian experts with space-relevant skills, a model that could work even better for cyber operations given the larger pool of civilian cyber professionals.
Cultural Innovation: Being a new service has allowed the Space Force to develop its own culture and approaches rather than being constrained by decades of traditional military practices.
My Privacy Blog
Challenges and Realistic Expectations
Implementation Hurdles
Creating a new military service isn't simple or quick:
Congressional Approval: Any new service requires congressional authorization, which can be a lengthy political process.
Budget Allocation: A $16.5 billion budget would need to be allocated, likely requiring reductions in other military spending or overall defense budget increases.
Personnel Transitions: Transferring proper IT personnel to the new branch would take time and could risk depleting essential staff already at CYBERCOM.
My Privacy Blog
Career Considerations
Uncertainty Period: Early career decisions would involve considerable uncertainty as the new service establishes its culture, promotion systems, and operational procedures.
Competitive Environment: A new service would likely attract high-quality candidates, creating a competitive environment for advancement.
Integration Challenges: Working effectively with other services and civilian agencies would require new coordination mechanisms and relationships.
Timeline and Next Steps
Near-Term Developments
Commission Report: The CSIS Commission is expected to deliver its recommendations in late 2025 or early 2026, providing detailed proposals for implementation.
Congressional Action: The National Defense Authorization Act process for 2026 and beyond will be crucial for any legislative action on creating a Cyber Force.
Pilot Programs: Even without a full Cyber Force, expect to see pilot programs testing new approaches to cyber force generation and career development.
My Privacy Blog
Long-Term Outlook
5-Year Horizon: If approved, a Cyber Force could begin operations within 5 years, creating immediate career opportunities for early adopters.
International Influence: Success of a U.S. Cyber Force could influence allied nations to adopt similar models, creating global career opportunities.
Industry Impact: A dedicated military cyber service would likely drive innovation and career development in the broader cybersecurity industry.
How to Position Yourself for Success
Build Relevant Skills
Technical Depth: Develop expertise in areas that military cyber operations prioritize, such as network operations, digital forensics, and threat hunting.
Policy Understanding: Learn about cyber doctrine, international law, and the intersection of technology and national security.
Leadership Experience: Any leadership experience, whether in technical teams or project management, will be valuable in a new service structure.
Stay Informed
Follow the Commission: Monitor CSIS and FDD publications for updates on commission findings and recommendations.
Engage with Community: Participate in cybersecurity conferences, especially those focused on government and military applications.
Educational Opportunities: Consider pursuing relevant graduate education or certifications in cybersecurity, particularly those with government or military focus.
Network Strategically
Government Connections: Build relationships with current government cyber professionals who might become leaders in a new service.
Industry Leaders: Connect with commission members and other industry leaders shaping cyber force development.
Military Cyber Community: Engage with current military cyber professionals to understand existing culture and practices.
The Bottom Line for Your Career
The potential creation of an independent U.S. Cyber Force represents one of the most significant career development opportunities in cybersecurity in decades. While there are no guarantees that Congress will approve such a service, the momentum building behind the idea suggests that significant changes to military cyber career paths are inevitable.
For cybersecurity professionals, this initiative offers the prospect of:
- Career advancement based on technical expertise rather than traditional military experience
- Leadership opportunities in a new, growing organization
- Direct application of civilian cyber skills to national security missions
- Participation in shaping entirely new approaches to cyber warfare and defense
Whether or not a full Cyber Force emerges, the current initiative is already driving improvements in how the military recruits, trains, and retains cyber professionals. The commission's work is highlighting long-standing problems and proposing solutions that will benefit cyber careers regardless of the final organizational outcome.
The key for cybersecurity professionals is to stay informed, build relevant skills, and position themselves to take advantage of new opportunities as they emerge. The next few years will be crucial in determining the future structure of military cyber operations—and the career opportunities that come with it.
As this initiative continues to develop, we'll be tracking the commission's progress and its implications for cybersecurity careers. Subscribe to our newsletter to stay updated on the latest developments in military cyber career opportunities.
About the Commission on Cyber Force Generation: Launched in 2025 by the Center for Strategic and International Studies in partnership with the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, the commission is examining how to implement an independent U.S. Cyber Force. The commission includes current and former government officials, independent experts, industry leaders, and civil society representatives.
